I may have mentioned it before, or I may have not, but Astro is not our first dog. Sam’s first dog was a mongrel named Rajah (after Princess Jasmine’s pet tiger in Disney’s Aladdin) who cried incessantly probably because he was separated from his mother much too soon. Rajah died and we buried him in my grandmother’s garden.
Then, Speedy bought her a mini-pinscher whom I christened Poco. Poco will be 12 years old this year and he is still with us.

That’s Poco the mini pin in the photo.
There was another mongrel after him, a beautiful white dog named Jack who was “given” by Speedy’s sister, Ava. To explain the quotation marks, Jack stayed with us because my father-in-law was terminally ill and a puppy was too much work for everyone. Jack was a beauty and we later discovered that the dog should have been named Jackie. A she, not a he, and no one knew until Sam looked under the fur. But her good looks were her only asset. She was an incorrigible dog who ate the mail, the water and electric bills and just about anything within reach. She died during the construction of the kitchen wing. We suspected that one of the workers fed her with something bad despite strict instructions from us not to feed the dogs anything. Anyway…
When Poco was still a puppy, there were inevitable discussions about whether to have his ears cut. It’s something “traditional” with mini pinschers, especially those entered in dog shows. I objected. My father had a Doberman named Sadie whose ears were trimmed. I saw what the dog had to go through (oh, yes, it is still surgery with anesthesia) and the dog’s discomfort with the bandages and, well… to put it simply, I just felt that it was cruel. Cutting the ears, risking infection, and for what? To make a dog more showy?
I’m writing about it now because the same discussion cropped up recently with regard to Astro. It seems that ear-trimming is also the “done thing” with pit bulls. Astro is not my dog, the final decision is not going to be mine, but I still hope that Sam will think long and hard before making any decision.
The thing that goes inside my head is how humans extend their obsession with looks and image to their pets as with just about anything they own — cars, houses, clothes, jewelry… Cutting the dog’s ears will not give it character. Every dog has character and smaller ears or a shorter tail will not add to it. Just as the perfect nose or boob job, egg sized diamonds or designer clothes do not make one a better person.
13 Responses
ed villanueva
April 22nd, 2008 at 5:29 pm
1When your dog is a Doberman then it should look like a doberman, so much so that this alteration becomes a common practice done by many dog lovers or are they?,they cut the ears and tails to look more on what they expect the breed should look like. Many apartment dwellers in Hong kong even have their dogs vocal chord altered so that they could no longer produce sound when barking, to the delight of the neighbors who doesnt like to be disturb by constant barking of the dogs even at night.arrkh…There is also this silly practice of coloring dogs hair and wearing them clothes for me its NOT cute.What do you think?
Connie Veneracion
April 22nd, 2008 at 7:10 pm
2I pity pets who have to bear all that. Altering vocal cords? My goodness, those people should just buy a robot dog.
isoebelle
April 22nd, 2008 at 7:51 pm
3the same with my dog before… pinaputulan din namin yun ears nya also the tail. it was my father who brought him to the vet. sabi kasi nila pangit daw tignan dahil malaki para sa size nila the same with the tail, mahaba. and it’s true kaya pumayag na rin ako. then sa diet naman sinabi ng vet na dapat daw less than a cup lang ipakain or else sosobra naman ang taba. ay naku! pati pala mga aso kailangan mag-diet.
Connie Veneracion
April 22nd, 2008 at 8:26 pm
4isoebelle, I think they get heart worm when they’re overweight. Poco is actually overweight now and my hubby and daughter tell me to stop feeding him so much hehehe
Ting
April 23rd, 2008 at 3:53 am
5I had my dog altered para hindi siya masyadong hyper, plus it was part of our agreement with the breeder (so we didn’t have any choice). Pero, I think it saved him from being the object of ridicule from children (laughing at his balls, yung isa pa nga hinila niya..muntik makagat). I love dressing my dog though especially on halloween. Weird ba?
Connie Veneracion
April 23rd, 2008 at 3:12 pm
6Ting, you mean he was neutered? Ako, I’m fine with dressing up pets. Ang ayoko lang talaga yung nasasaktan sila unnecessarily. Here’s something weird. We used to keep an aquarium. But after watching “Finding Nemo” I refused to keep any more pet fish.
BlogusVox
April 23rd, 2008 at 4:24 pm
7“But after watching “Finding Nemo” I refused to keep any more pet fish.”
Yeah, I understand, it does something to your mind.
Bubbles, bubbles… my bubbles!
ed villanueva
April 23rd, 2008 at 6:29 pm
8dogs has its fur to protect itself from elements they dont have any sweat gland so they uses their tongue to help cool themselves when the weather is hot or when they feel hot,if you wear clothes on your dog you might raise their body temperature and imagine the agony they will endure sticking out their tongue the whole day to cool off aside from irritating them ,they may look cute to you but its stressful to them.
Connie Veneracion
April 23rd, 2008 at 9:26 pm
9Ah BlogusVox, it’s more than that. You have to ask why Pixar and Disney choose such themes. They’re supposed to make an impact on the young. Can’t teach adults new ideas but the young… ah there’s the answer.
Ed, you have a point there.
Ting
April 24th, 2008 at 1:16 am
10Connie, yes. Dito, “altered” is more often used as opposed to “neutered” or “spayed”. (Or should I say the “new” term).
Connie Veneracion
April 24th, 2008 at 2:25 am
11ah yan gusto ko gawin sa pusa ni Sam na buntis three times a year.
mikee
April 26th, 2008 at 3:09 am
12Where these practices originated is quite justified, just that today’s dog’s are mostly in the city and not there guarding flocks of sheeps.
Actually, yes, cropped ears do give dogs characters, characters enough to be more intimidating for wolves to come near the flock the dogs were guarding. It’s very functional and it is actually the original purpose of “working Dogs,” from these category is where the German Shepherds, Great Pyrenees, Dobermans etc came from.
Another example, the original reason for tail cropping of “working dogs” is to avoid confusions for their counterpart “hound (hunting) dogs” (Basset Hounds, Beagles, English Springer Spaniels). Because in a typical farm setting, there should be working dogs to guard and tend the flock while the hound dogs hunt for wolves in the nearby forest so they can sue them in advance. Now since the working dogs don’t have the instinct of the hound signals commonly channeled on the hounds’ tails, the tails of working dogs are cropped so as not to confuse the hounds.
You make think too, that the fancy clipping of poodles’ balloony “hair-do” are all for aesthetics. The original purpose for that haircut is to make them swim faster with the legs completely bald while the pawpads were all haired up to serve as a paddle for faster swimming. Then their head and chest hairs were kept to protect those part from freezing. The balloony fur on the tail was also kept as it serves as a signaling tool (kept above the water).
So to say, the original purpose were mostly based on functions. But I can’t say too that today’s are all about aesthetics, because conformation showing (beauty contest equivalent) of dogs are all done to showcase a thorough breeding and good bloodline (hence the done for the betterment of the breed).
Gail
May 1st, 2008 at 4:56 am
13We used to have this dog who loved wearing sweaters so much during December. She gets real cold at night, but we took her sweater off in the morning so she won’t get too warm. She would take the sweater from the coffee table and drop it in front of me or the maid whenever we forgot to put on her sweater for her at night fall.
Dog clothes can also be functional and not just for “cute” purposes. Sometimes using them are necessary to keep dogs warm, especially for short-haired and hairless breeds during cold weather. I dress my dogs during the cold season (you’d see how happy they are being able to play instead of shivering under blankets), but we shave their fur during the summer or let them stay inside air-conditioned areas in the house. What can I say? We just love and spoil our dogs
I think the same applies to cutting or not cutting Astro’s ears. If there isn’t any function for it (I honestly don’t see any), I don’t see why his ears should be cut. You aren’t planning to enter him in dog shows or become his pimp (ie. stud service hehee) are you? If you’re not, then I really do hope your family will let him keep his ears
RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI
Please post comments responsibly
Recent Comments
Tags
announcements Antipolo art Asia Astro Avilon Zoo Baguio Batangas beach cats dining dog entertainment family & parenting flowers food Gadgets government Health Laguna Legal issues Metro Manila mommies op-ed column Panagbenga Philippines photography potpourri Quezon City reading resort sexuality shopping Subic Taipei Taiwan technology travel work Zoobic SafariRecent Posts
Where I write
Credits