They don’t make movies like ‘Chinatown’ anymore
My head feels like it’s floating and it’s been this way since I got out of bed this morning. See, I stayed up until 1.00 a.m. to watch Chinatown.
When Chinatown was shown in the local movie houses, I was still in grade school. When it was nominated in the Oscar Awards, I saw the trailer in the televised awards night and it intrigued me no end. In the trailer, Jack Nicholson was asking Faye Dunaway who “Catherine” was and she said, “She’s my daughter.” Jack Nicholson slapped her and she said, “My sister.” Another slap and, “My daughter.” Slap. “My sister.” Slap. “My daughter.” Until, finally, falling from the blow of the last slap, Faye Dunaway said, “She’s my sister AND my daughter.” When you’re in the fourth grade, you don’t really know what incest means (I didn’t even know the word at the time) and a scene like that is both scary and mind-blowing.
When I finally saw Chinatown in college (on VHS), I was already a big fan of film noir and Roman Polanski, the latter because I had seen Rosemary’s Baby and Tess, a requirement for an English Literature class. And when I saw the schedule on Cinemax last night, I couldn’t resist despite the late hour.
In one sense, it is a good thing that I was not allowed to see the film until I was ready for it. While it would have been easy to understand the relationships between the characters, a child would have been lost in the bigger plot.
Ostensibly, the story is about a suspicious wife who wanted her husband followed by a private detective. The wife turned out to be an impostor and the detective was hired under false pretenses to ruin the reputation of the Chief Engineer of Los Angeles’ water department. The engineer, Hollis Mulwray, was suspected of seeing another woman and the detective was supposed to get the proof. The proof — photographs of Mulwray and a young girl — landed on the front page of newspapers (that’s the detective’s sideline — paparazzi work).
Ruining the engineer’s reputation was only a small part of a sinister plot. Mulwray was against the building of a dam amid a drought in Los Angeles, a plot that was based on the true-to-life water wars in California during the first quarter of the 20th century. Mulwray’s refusal to allow the building of the dam frustrated the business plans of some “investors” who had been forcing out farmers to sell their dried-up lands at dirt cheap prices. With the building of the dam, the area would be irrigated, the value of the land would skyrocket and the “investors” would make tremendous profits.
Mulwray was murdered and his widow — the real one — became a suspect. The private detective was caught in the middle with his professional reputation in the balance. The young girl photographed with Mulwray was a key witness as having been the last person to see him alive.
The story twists when the detective, Jake Gittes, found the girl and Mulwray’s widow in a house when they weren’t even supposed to know each other. This is the part when the memorable slapping-and-my-daughter-my-sister scene took place. The girl, in fact the widow’s daughter, was also the granddaughter of the powerful and wealthy ex-partner of Mulwray in the water business back in the days when water was a privately owned commodity.
The girl’s father, Noah Cross, was also the buyer of the poor farmers’ lands. He was buying the lands using the names of nearly senile residents of a nursing home who had no idea that they were being used.
You might not have seen the movie yet so I won’t say how it ended. Suffice to say that the title, Chinatown, was a symbol. Gittes, an ex-cop, used to work the Chinatown beat and it embodied the totality of his life’s regrets as well as its incomprehensibilities.
It is themes like those of Chinatown that convinces me that writing — opinion writing, specifically — ought not be limited to what is current. There are themes that are relevant today and will stay relevant next year and even ten years from now. Timeless themes like that of Chinatown.

A third of what’s been written about me is true, a third is half-true and the rest consists of drug-induced hallucinations. I suppose I’d better let me, rather than them, tell you 
17 responses to "They don’t make movies like ‘Chinatown’ anymore"
Ang tagal na nun. I think I was in high school when I first saw it. The only thing I remember was the slapping and the cutting of Nicholson’s nose. Your summary refreshes my mind.
Film noir? Hmmm …. The Betsy.
parang inulit kanina yan sa cinemax. nadaanan ko lang while channel surfing. hindi ko kasi kilala kaya nilagpasan ko. panonoorin ko ‘to pag pinalabas ulit. he he.
BlogusVox, Harold Robbins’ The Betsy?
Gloria, naku, don’t miss it. Paminsan-minsan lang ako maka-tiyempo ng type ko na movie. One movie I saw before and never again (censored version although I didn’t know it until I did my research afterwards) was Mulholland Drive. Ang galing!
Yup. Rich, powerful and really sick people.
I saw Chinatown at a Film Class around 2 years ago, and I liked the detective plot of it. When we reached the ending, we were all numb from what took place, and still had that feeling minutes and even hours after watching it. One word: Brilliant! =)
I saw Chinatown at a Film Class around 2 years ago, and I liked the detective plot of it. When we reached the ending, we were all numb from what took place, and still had that feeling minutes and even hours after watching it. Frankly we didn’t expect that to happen. One word: Brilliant! =)
Ugh, sorry for double-posting!!! =P
BlogusVox, yes, very. And there was no rape so it was consensual incest.
JM, if you’re into Polanski’s work, I suggest you see Rosamary’s Baby hehehehe The ending is just as brilliant.
I hate the ending of this film. Is there no justice in the world?
Naku, even with you explaining the plot, I find myself still scratching my head. Pero I do remember that scene when I watched it as a young child. And I was extremely blown away by what the woman was admitting. I can’t believe it was Faye Dunaway.
I should pick this up again from the local Blockbuster.
LOL, you were still in grade school when you watched Chinatown and I was, I think, in my college 2nd year. The first time I’ve appreciated a really beautiful legs of a woman. (I can not believe she was the same Faye Dunaway that I’ve seen in one of the later CSI episodes).
BTW, if I’m not mistaken, The Betsy did not make it in theaters. Instead it was shown as TV-movie.
pinayhekmi, it’s one of those plot within a plot and everything is connected to something that happened which is not part of the movie hehehe
Trosp, college na rin ako when I saw Chinatown hehehe Grade school when it was shown in movie houses. I remember hindi ako isinama sa sine ng nanay ko kas For Adults Only.
what a coincidence. last night, i just watched “the two jakes,” the sequel to “chinatown.” it’s a good movie but not as engaging as the original which is certainly a classic. apparently, the whole story was conceived as a trilogy (see jack nicholson’s interview in the dvd special features-he directed 2 jakes since polanski could not step foot in the u.s. anymore) but the last installment was never made-too many problems. so if you’re curious about what happened to catherine, i suggest you watch it.
Flash - your favorite Brokeback Mountain star Heath Ledger was found dead in his home in NY City.
Trosp, The Betsy made it to the theaters. I’m still in high school when I saw it in a theater in my hometown (around late ’70s).
Ronnel, that makes the story realistic, ‘di ba? Justice is such a dream most times.
Jojo, oooohh, so Catherine is in the sequel. I wonder where I can get a copy of The Two Jakes…
Josh, yes, I read about Heath Ledger yesterday. How tragic. The family says it was an accident and not suicide.
i completely agree with you - they don’t make film noir like they used to. although i’m a big fan of the coen brothers because they can do noir RIGHT (you seen Blood Simple?) anyway, nice recap of a great film. makes me wanna go out and buy the DVD (havent done so yet). last time i saw the film was 2001. as for the sequel (The Two Jakes), i hear it’s crap. oh the burden sequels must bear.
Leave a comment